Scirocco manual vs dsg

Manual is generally more reliable, because to ruin it you either suck at driving manual or upgrade the power and clutch starts slipping etc. Vw scirocco r dsg 265 hp vs vw scirocco manual 210 hp. The scirocco r is definitely better at fuel economy than my mustang. In short, the dsg is a great transmission, but id personally always go manual especially in a car like the gti, where the manual box is a beauty and its a blast to zip around shifting your own gears. However, the reality is about 15 mpg in mostly city driving, and usually only 23 mpg on the highway. The scirocco s dsg felt exactly like the golfs did when it. It was manufactured with various petrol and diesel engines, and was available with both manual and automatic transmission style.

Home autocatalog volkswagen scirocco 2008 scirocco 3rd 2. May 18, 2011 ive done the switch from dsg to manual. Ive driven several dsg golfs r32s and a chipped diesel and i think the box is amazing. With his dsgequipped scirocco, hes backing the future.

At the end of the day, get whats best for you, not what is best for everyone else. The scirocco is at least for this generation of the car only being imported in the topend r specification. In simple terms, a dsg automates two separate manual gearboxes and. Planting the accelerator and ripping through the gears with the paddles. Ive had both, dsg in scirocco 140tdi form and a manual in gtd form and all going well the gti im swapping for will be manual too. Its 2 litre engine is a turbocharged, double overhead camshaft, 4 cylinder unit that has an output of 207. The scirocco derives its name from the mediterranean wind. Oct 29, 2015 at the end of the day, get whats best for you, not what is best for everyone else.

Curious to know how significant the variance is between manual and dsg models. Manual vs dsg is such a personal thing, the only opinion that matters is your own. As for manual vs dsg, we all know a dsg is only quicker on paper. Based on the golf, it was designed to offer the same quality and composed drive as the gti, but with a higher level of practicality than most. In fact i go as far as saying more than half the golf r cars local to me in my price range were dsg. Interior, if a tad conservative, is well put together. Maybe i just need to give it more time and perhaps live with it for a while before. Once you get comfortable with their performance characteristics, its a pretty solid transmission. Test drive originally intended to be a comment to my previous post, i decided to make this a new post instead. The scirocco retains the funky spirit of the original but blends this with modern practicality and driving satisfaction. For me i was almost on the fence bw choosing manual or dsg until i found out canadian dsg tdis dont come with the shifter paddle.

The scirocco s dsg felt exactly like the golfs did when it was brand new. The debate over manual and auto will go on for a long time, i suspect those that are in favour of manual having been driving a relatively shorter time than those of us that love the dsg, i certainly do not miss anything about a manual, im not even sure where less involved arrives from, having driven manuals in between, gear changing now seems. May 20, 2009 according to the german firm, the scirocco r hits the 100kmh 62mph mark in 6. Id like to hear the pros and cons of each transmission from. My old cars are manual and thats part of the reason for having them but the tig is the car to get around in comfortably and easily, as well as mrs j having back issues, so no brainer for us. I was in the same boat a few years ago when buying a mk5 golf gti. A couple even postulate it is simply a golf gti in a little black dress. Nov 14, 2014 volkswagen groups dsg gearbox explained. Im only interested in knowing the performance statistics on a stock nonchipped u. All prices retail, delivery and rotr are recommended by volkswagen ireland.

I now have not a love hate relationship but a love why did you change up then. The dual clutch automatic dsg transmission is a joy to use with quick and efficient gearshifts when needed. Since the transmission is built like a manual, it is mechanically strong. Ive not experienced the lurch that mczzippy refers to. But australian buyers have spent decades lusting after the small coupe in vain.

The manual may be more fun, but the dsg is one of the better dual clutches out there. I would venture to say it is the best affordable one, from what i have heard. The volkswagen scirocco is a coupe version of the ubiquitous golf hatchback. I find the manual gear change is light and precise, and the clutch pedal weight feels good. Its weird because i wouldnt mind taking the dsg now but i love the manual. I find myself engaging manual mode most times to do simple things on the road that i wouldnt have to do when driving the tsi. Scirocco central view topic scirocco r manual or dsg.

At the time i expected to use it more around the m25 so auto was a good option for the crawl. No auto or dsg will ever be able to simulate actually rowing your own gears. Dsg or manual vw golf r mk7 chat vwroc vw r owners club. The claimed 8,0 l100 km is slightly optimistic as even driving it in the most leisurely fashion returned 10,0 l100 km, according to the onboard computer. Direkt, commonly abbreviated to dsg, is an electronically. Stick versus paddles or manual versus dsg is a difficult question, as we found out. The volkswagen club of south africa the volkswagen club of south africa technical discussions technical.

Manual box wont let you over or under rev it but youre in charge. Dsg vs manual page 5 the volkswagen club of south africa. Amazing in that u cannot feel the gear changes up or down only feel it change from 1st to 2nd, amazing that under full throttle accelaration, there is no pause in g force as it changes gear. Indeed, volkswagen has now enhanced this with the facelifted model, adding further polish to the package. New volkswagen scirocco r car information singapore sgcarmart. Wouldnt mind knowing other performance oriented stats like.

Volkswagen scirocco automatik gebraucht kaufen autoscout24. This model has been on sale in europe since 2008 but arrives here, midlifecycle, for the first time. We have 26 cars for sale for volkswagen scirocco r dsg, priced from zar9,900. By using this site you agree to the use of cookies. As zubair said in the pieces that he copied from the internet, dsg is awesome and it is constantly in power. New grille and headlamp design introduces the new face of vw. At gti international i went up against a stock manual gti in my stock dsg gti. A future in which the business of changing gear swiftly and smoothly is idiotproof. Problem with my 2015 scirocco r dsg gearbox page 1. Volkswagen sharan volkswagen scirocco volkswagen tiguan 2011. Sport seats look and feel great, but should drop lower.

Plenty of threads on ph and the internet about the manual v dsg subject. In the past, volkswagen was concerned that the scirocco would hit. Scirocco manual or dsg ebook vw dsg service manual ebook vw dsg service manual ebook 7 speed dsg workshop manual credits bfinances if you are looking for the ebook 7 speed dsg workshop manual in pdf form, in that case you come on to. I am considering purchasing a 2019 gti, most likely the rabbit edition. Take full control of the vehicle by switching the gearbox to manual shift mode, and use the gear stick or the flappy paddles to change gear. That means sports seats, a 15mm lower ride height than the regular model and massive 19inch rims. Vw owned audi has its dct termed as stronic, porsche calls it pdk as per which types. The salesperson chatted excitedly about the scirocco r being turbocharged, the adaptive chassis control, its sixspeed manual or dsg gearbox. View topic having second thoughts about manual vs dsg. The minuses are cost both purchase price and ongoing maintenance costs. Plus here in the states its a little harder to find than the normal dsg based vehicles. I hate autos and had a dsg r32 for 5 years and loved the dsg box. Also called twinclutch or dct gearboxes, a dsg automatic gearbox is offered on many cars now.

I wanted a manual and wasnt at all interested in dsg. Its been a long time since there was any talk from volkswagen regarding a small, affordable sports coupe. You shouldnt be that much less happy if you do choose dsg over manual. It includes absolutely every element of service, repair and maintenance including schematics covered in simple pdf format. With his dsg equipped scirocco, hes backing the future. The edmunds longterm 2015 volkswagen golf gti comes with the optional dsg automatic. Dsg vs manual golfmk7 vw gti mkvii forum vw golf r. Explanation and advantage of the feature will be shown. But i do think its the right car for busy southern england roads. There are advantages and disagvantages but i would say the manual is more enjoyable in a car you will be working hard. Dsg aka directshift gearbox is a type of dct aka dual clutch transmission dsg is a term used by volkswagen group of cars like vw polo or skoda octavia dsg etc. This weekend i took the opportunity to test drive two otherwise identical sciroccos 1. Ive done a dsg reset through my tuner with vagcom and even that didnt seem to help anything. A future the playstation generation will slot right into.

View and download volkswagen scirocco product manual online. Volkswagen groups dsg gearbox explained autoevolution. Volkswagen scirocco service repair manual volkswagen. What i was suprised to notice was how smooth the dsg was compared to my golf. The volkswagen scirocco r dsg s engine is a turbocharged petrol, 2 litre, double overhead camshaft 4 cylinder with 4 valves per cylinder. Automotive editor james riswick advocates sticking with the manual. However, when i bought my rocco i chose a manual for change. May 30, 2011 this weekend i took the opportunity to test drive two otherwise identical sciroccos 1. The dsg box brings this car a lot closer to the price of a manual 2. I answer another one of the questions i frequently get asked. Mar 28, 2006 dsg vs manual is abit like, silver vs black. I have only owned manuals but i have driven a scirocco dsg and a golf vi manual recently.

The gte was available with either the 4speed manual transmission or the. If you value more driver involvement i think the dsg can be somewhat involving when used manually over faster gear changes and the convenience of an auto then the manual might be the right choice. Its goodlooking, wellbuilt and wellsorted coupe with power and classless appeal. Volkswagen scirocco free workshop and repair manuals. Vw scirocco r dsg 265 hp vs vw scirocco manual 210. A future of seamless, computeraided upshifts and revmatched, lurchfree downshifts. I chose a dsg when i went for a scirocco r coming from a manual golf gti.

Find all the key specs about the volkswagen scirocco coupe 2. The 1984 model year saw the return of two windshield wipers vs the large. As a vw mechanic for many years, all i can say is that in my experience, they seem to be very reliable. I think about this subject all of the time and question my decision for purchasing a manual. Ive had my 2015 scirocco r for over a year now, saved up to get this. Scirocco dsg, quick question page 1 audi, vw, seat. The current volkswagen scirocco was launched in 2008. Well that was a long talk, but i say go with whatever you want, its your car, your the one whose. This is my first dsg so i cant exactly tell you due to my switch from manual to dsg, but if you tune to car or upgrade the power, it is possible to have issues unless you do dsg tuning. As has been said already in this thread, the manual version is also cheaper to buy than the dsg and unlike the dsg, the manual gearbox doesnt require servicing oil change at 40k. The vw golf r is good but is it better with a dsg or manual gearbox. Dsg is just a preferenceoptions and weather its better than manual or not is. I put it in s mode and whack it from get go, i am always the one changing gears at the desired rpm, then put it back in d and it becomes all.

If you are thinking of mapping at a later date go for the manual. It is only available as a threedoor, and has less space in the. The company obviously took note of what people would want from said car though, because this latest generation scirocco appears to fit the bill. Remeber the dsg is an automated manual so still has a clutch, etc but the car does all the work. Scirocco central view topic manual vs dsg question. Ive seen a van which ticks all the boxes for me, however its dsg and i wasnt overly impressed with it when i test drove it.

This unit has an output of 261 bhp 265 ps195 kw of power at 6000 rpm, and maximum torque of 350 nm 258 lbft35. The volkswagen scirocco h as been the german brands sportiest looking model since its debut in 2008. The dsg shifts faster than a human can, therefore the dsg has a faster 060 time than the manual. The paddles are active all the time, in drive or sport they will give you. As a nameplate, scirocco has been around since the 1970s and predates even the golf. For me i love the manual, its great, allows me control gives me a connection. I was kinda glad bout the fact because it made me go for 6sp without hesitate. Three generations of this car was produced, with the third generation in the market from 2008. Ive got a 2 litre dsg scirocco with 19s and its pretty impressive. Currently it appears as though the dsg transmissions have solid longevity.